The slow cooker timer rings while you’re setting the Thanksgiving table. Before you add the butter and start mashing, lift out a few potato cubes from different parts of the pot. One tender piece at the edge tells you little about the pieces in the center.

Test several cubes before you mash the batch
The slow cooker method from Intentional Hospitality cooks cubed potatoes with milk in the appliance. Follow its quantities, cooker size and heat setting. Cut the potatoes into even pieces so the batch has a more consistent starting point. At the end of the recipe’s cooking window, a fork should pass through each test piece without meeting a firm center.
If some cubes resist, cover the cooker and give them more time. Put the butter and serving dish back on the counter while the potatoes finish. A timer helps you plan the meal, but the fork check tells you whether the potatoes are ready for the next step.
Add the finishing ingredients once the potatoes are tender
Use a potato masher and add the recipe’s butter and cream as directed. Stop to check the texture as you go. Taste before adjusting the salt, then check whether you want a little more liquid. Keep the lid nearby so you can cover the finished mash while you finish another dish.
Check the holding temperature before dinner
Once cooked, switch to the warming setting according to the appliance manual. USDA recommends keeping hot food at 140°F or above. Use a thermometer to check the mash before putting it on the buffet.
If you cooked and refrigerated the potatoes ahead, reheat them to 165°F on the stove or in the microwave before transferring them to a preheated cooker. USDA advises against reheating cold leftovers in a slow cooker. If the corn is taking that appliance, reserve it first in your Thanksgiving cooking plan.